The Energy of Giving a ‘No Remark’ Interview Throughout Police Questioning

August 30, 2023by Naomi Cramer

Have you ever simply came upon that you’ve got been referred to as in for a police interview? In that case, you won’t know what to anticipate and also you’re in all probability frightened about what would possibly occur. You may need even heard that the perfect factor to do is to say ‘no remark’ to regardless of the police ask you. However why? And what implications does saying no remark have to your case? On this article, we’ll clarify why you would possibly or won’t, on stability, need to say no remark at a police interview.

What does it imply in case you say ‘no remark’ in a police interview?

Saying no remark at a police interview means, merely, that you’re refusing to say something in response to the questions being requested or the allegations being made towards you by the interviewing officer.

You’ll be able to say no remark for everything of your police interview or simply for a part of it (for instance, for the elements the place you would not have authorized illustration current and aren’t positive what to say for worry of incriminating your self).

Does no remark indicate guilt?

Technically talking, saying no remark will not be an request for forgiveness, nor a proclamation of innocence. It solely means that you’re exercising your proper to stay silent and won’t be offering any additional info or giving an account of what occurred, till you determine in any other case.

Whereas which will make sense from a extra educational perspective, many individuals do fear concerning the sensible implications of going the no remark route. Understandably, many individuals have issues that saying no remark may be seen as an oblique request for forgiveness as a result of it’d counsel that you’ve got one thing to cover. That is utterly comprehensible, however it is best to attempt to keep in mind that the police aren’t capable of cost anybody with a crime based mostly solely on taking the no remark method to the interview. And, after all, a court can not discover you responsible merely due to that motive, both.

With that in thoughts, when is it a good suggestion to reply no remark, and when is it a foul one?

Why give no remark at a police interview?

Regardless of issues over potential drawbacks to giving no remark at a police interview, there are some actual sensible benefits to doing so. These embody:

  • Having the ability to take the time to consider what you’re saying with out feeling rushed or pressured by the police.
  • Realizing that your solutions will solely be on document in a approach that may’t be used towards you in court, as no remark statements don’t typically rely as proof in felony proceedings (with some exceptions).
  • It being far simpler to disclaim any allegations or fees if in case you have not explicitly stated something that may very well be used as proof towards you.
  • Not having to confess to different conduct that’s not unlawful, however might nonetheless embarrass or injury you.
  • Being given time to recall reminiscences correctly if the case is especially previous or complicated.

Are there any circumstances through which I ought to reply police questions?

However, there are some conditions through which it won’t be useful to say no remark at a police interview. For instance:

  • Should you imagine that the police have ample proof to cost you with a crime, irrespective of the way you reply their questions.
  • If the police are asking you a query that’s solely meant to determine your identification or fundamental particulars and isn’t associated to felony exercise.
  • If it may be higher to reply honestly with the intention to present particulars of who really dedicated the crime, as a substitute of dealing with fees your self.

For the reason that introduction of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994, it could even be to your benefit to keep away from saying no remark at a police interview to make sure that no inferences could also be drawn about your determination to stay silent. This can be a very complicated sensible and procedural matter that needs to be dealt with in session together with your felony defence solicitor.

Ought to I reply no remark at a police interview?

The underside line is that, with out figuring out the main points of your particular state of affairs, nobody can let you know what the precise proper factor to do is in a police interview. It relies upon fully in your particular person case and circumstances.

For example, if you’re harmless however nonetheless suppose the police have sufficient proof to cost you with a crime, it may be higher to reply police questions honestly as a substitute of giving no remark to have it on document that you just tried to cooperate with the police from the beginning of their investigations. It will assist your claims of innocence in a while.

In the end, you’re the one in charge of your solutions in police interviews, and solely you’ll be able to determine if you wish to chorus from answering questions. That being stated, in case you do select to go along with a no remark method, it’s crucial that you just safe the recommendation of a good felony defence solicitor who can advise you in your choices and any potential optimistic or destructive penalties upfront.

Does everybody have the precise to silence in an interview?

Within the Auckland, you will have the precise to stay silent in a police interview and might select to say no remark or to remain utterly mute throughout the interview. The police even inform you of this at first of the interview or on the time of your arrest by saying:

‘You would not have to say something, however it could hurt your defence if you don’t point out when questioned one thing which you later depend on in court. Something you do say may be given in proof.’

Simply because you will have the precise to stay silent doesn’t essentially imply, nevertheless, that it is best to train it. As we’ve seen, there may be compelling the reason why it is best to, or shouldn’t, take the no remark method.

How does a lawyer determine whether or not it is best to say no remark or not?

Any respected felony defence lawyer may have spent a whole lot upon a whole lot of hours with suspected criminals in police interviews. From this first-hand expertise, they are going to be capable to assess the large image of your state of affairs and determine whether or not it’s higher to cooperate totally with the police or to reply with no remark.

Among the components a lawyer will take note of embody:

  • particulars you will have supplied about your whereabouts and involvement (or lack thereof) within the case
  • any earlier arrests or convictions you will have for related offences
  • any psychological well being issues, diagnoses, or disabilities which will have an effect on your means to reply questions precisely
  • present or prior habit points which will have an effect on your cognitive talents
  • any vulnerabilities comparable to notably younger or previous age, bodily or psychological disabilities, or historical past of being abused
  • your demonstrated emotional power and the chance of you ‘holding it collectively’ throughout the interview

Are you able to say no remark in court?

Each defendant has a privilege towards self-incrimination, together with at trial, which implies that you’re entitled to depend on the precise to stay silent if you want to take action. You could stay silent within the face of questions from the choose, from your individual lawyer, or from the prosecution.

Whether or not it’s a good suggestion to stay silent in court is, nevertheless, one other matter fully. Typically talking, it not a good suggestion to stay silent in court as a result of the inference of guilt is a lot stronger, however some lawyers will advise it if they’re extremely sceptical of the power of the prosecution’s case or if they don’t suppose it’s a good suggestion for the defendant to talk (in the event that they battle to carry their composure, are prone to get confused, or would act angrily, for instance).

Solely a lawyer who has all of the related particulars of your case can advise on how finest to proceed with answering questions in court.

Are you able to say no remark as a witness?

Typically, witnesses aren’t allowed to say no remark if they’ve been summoned to court to serve in a trial. The one exception to that is if their feedback would result in self-incrimination.

Witnesses who aren’t vulnerable to self-incrimination however who refuse to reply some or all questions could also be held in contempt of court.

The place to get extra recommendation on no remark methods?

No remark is a robust instrument throughout a police interview, however it’s critical to keep in mind that there are some dangers related to not answering any questions. Should you’re not sure about what to do in your particular case, it’s best to talk with an skilled felony defence lawyer who may also help information you thru the method. At Stuart Miller Solicitors, we’ve years of expertise serving to clients determine whether or not to reply police questions or take the no remark method. Contact us at present for a free session and extra recommendation on find out how to deal with questioning throughout a police interview.


  • Responsive

    A authorized skilled will seek the advice of you inside 24 hours of constructing an enquiry.

  • Empathetic

    We are going to at all times deal with you with belief, understanding and respect.

  • Specialised

    Your case shall be dealt with by an skilled who specialises in your sort of offence.

  • Proactive

    We are going to take early motion to finish proceedings as quickly as it’s virtually and legally doable to take action.

  • Engaged

    You can be saved up to date in your case always. We are going to present a named contact accessible to reply your questions.

  • Caring

    We perceive this can be a tough and nerve-racking time for you and your family. Our workforce will assist you each step of the way in which.

  • Tenacious

    We are going to by no means surrender in your case. We battle tirelessly to get you the absolute best final result.



Source link

by Naomi Cramer

Auckland Lawyer for FIRST TIME Offenders Seeking to Avoid a Conviction. Family Law Expert in Child Care Custody Disputes. If you are facing Court Naomi will make you feel comfortable every step of the way.  As a consummate professional your goals become hers, with customer service as our top priority. It has always been Naomi’s philosophy to approach whatever you do in life with bold enthusiasm and pure dedication. Complement this with her genuine passion for equal justice and rights for all and you have the formula for success. Naomi is a highly skilled Court lawyer having practised for more than 20 years. She serves the greater Auckland region and can travel to represent clients throughout NZ With extensive experience, an analytical eye for detail, and continuing legal education Naomi’s skill set will maximise your legal rights whilst offering a holistic approach that best fits your individual needs. This is further enhanced with her high level of support and understanding. Naomi will redefine what you expect from your legal professional, facilitating a seamless experience from start to finish.   Her approachable and adaptive demeanor serves her well when working with the diverse cultures that make up the Auckland region. Blend her open and honest approach to her transparent process and you can see why she routinely delivers the satisfying results her clients deserve. If you want to maximise your legal rights, we recommend you book an appointment with Naomi today so she can detail the steps for you to achieve your goals. 

error: Content is protected !!